The Nebraska Supreme Courtroom on Friday largely overturned a decrease court docket and held an insurer should pay additional bills related to a enterprise that moved to a renovated facility after a hearth.
Outdated Mill Bulk Meals is a deli/grocery retailer that operated in a rented constructing in Valentine, Nebraska, in line with the ruling by the Nebraska Supreme Courtroom in North Star Mutual Insurance coverage Co. v. Jerry Miller and David Miller, doing enterprise as Outdated Mill Bulk Meals.
in July 2018, a hearth destroyed its premises and Outdated Mill determined to renovate one other constructing by which to relocate its enterprise. It sought $159,878, along with different reimbursements, from its insurer, Cottonwood, Minnesota-based North Star Mutual Insurance coverage Co., below its coverage’s additional expense provision, in line with the choice.
North Star denied protection, and a district court docket dominated within the insurer’s favor, aside from $4,600 for a walk-in cooler. It additionally held that Outdated Mill was entitled to solely $5,000 of its request for $33,797 in attorneys charges.
The state excessive court docket dominated in a unanimous choice that the retailer was entitled to additional expense protection below its coverage.
“Concluding that the coverage is ambiguous and due to this fact construing it in favor of Outdated Mill, we decide as a matter of legislation that the ‘Additional Expense’ provision of the Coverage supplies protection for prices related to electrical enhancements, plumbing enhancements, structural enhancements, and supplies related to these enhancements that have been achieved to the alternative premises,” it stated.
The court docket, which affirmed the award for the walk-in cooler, remanded the problem of the attorneys charges again to the trial court docket in mild of its additional expense holding.
Attorneys within the case didn’t reply to requests for remark.